The Unlikely Couple

Hi. I'm Ricky, a 20 year old student from Lancaster, Massachusetts. I'm writing to you to tell you about the greatest fuck of my life. But the circumstances under which it happened were a little odd, and I thought maybe you'd be able to advise me about it.

Just before my senior year I came home from college to visit my family for the weekend. I had gone through a pretty rough break-up with my college girlfriend of two years. Sympathetically, my sister Erica wanted to fix me up with her friend Taffy. I didn't really know Taffy, but I'd seen her a couple of times with Erica while visiting home, and she's definitely cute. Whenever we met we never said anything. I'd get unusually shy around her. I guess we both would. Definite chemistry there.

Taffy, my sister and I were all the same age. Erica is my fraternal twin. I went off to college and she went to cosmetology school, where she met Taffy. Erica and I have always been very close, and never fought much like other siblings do. We've also been very protective of each other. I never liked her boyfriends and she certainly didn't like my ex girlfriend. So it's no wonder she wanted to fix me up with Taffy. Erica and Taffy are joined at the hip--wearing the same clothes, and Taffy recently moved in to my old bedroom at my parents' house, just across the hall from Erica.

Being guilty of the same possessiveness, I brought my best friend and roommate Edwin home with me on this trip. I figured perhaps he and Erica might like each other. Tit for tat. Since Erica and I share many interests, as I do with Edwin, I was sure they'd get along great.

We were going to double date at Erica's favorite pub. Erica and Taffy both wore really short skirts. While getting out of the car, my sister playfully hiked her skirt up from behind to show me she wasn't wearing underwear, then whispered to me that Taffy wasn't wearing any either. I found that sort of intimidating. I didn't really intend to get laid on day one. I'm just not that forward.

So there we are at a pub, paired up on either side of a booth. I didn't want to seem too forward with Taffy, but Edwin and Erica really hit it off. It was electric. They were laughing and she was really pressed up against him. I really admired how cool Edwin could be with her. His arm was around her and it seemed like they had known each other for years.

Taffy and I were being shy, as usual. Mainly watching Edwin and Erica. Taffy managed to sneak her way under my arm as well. Her firm, curvaceous body felt great against me, she smelled terrific, and the thought of her naked pussy being just under that little flap of skirt did have an effect on me.

The same thoughts must have been playing at Edwin, too, because by the time our meals arrived at our table, he and my sister had stopped talking and were open-mouth kissing. I nervously laughed, hoping I wasn't disappointing Taffy by not kissing her. I felt like a loser. Eventually the girls got up to go to the bathroom.

"God damnit, Ricky, your sister is HOT!" Edwin whispered across the table. "I hope you don't mind me making out with her so soon right in front of you!"

"Don't sweat it," I assured him. "Better you than some other guy."

"So what's the deal with Taffy, don't you like her? She's really into you." He said.

"You think so? I don't want to make any assumptions."

"Definitely, man!" He laughed. "She's just waiting for you to plant one on her! I'm surprised you can't tell. It's obvious the girls set this whole thing up for you, and here I am getting lucky instead."

Now I felt even less confident, not picking up the signals. I figured I'd go to the men's room and double check my appearance and do my screw-up-some-courage routine in front of the mirror.

On my way to the rest room, Erica came out and grabbed me by the arm. "I'll say this to you once, brother," she mumbled, "Taffy is pretty easy, she's had the hots for you since she first met you two years ago, and her ass is yours for the taking--so make a move!"

"Right, got it." I stammered as I shouldered the door to the men's room. I took a pee and washed up and checked my hair and breath. All three of them were probably sitting in there, debating whether or not I was going to do anything.

Performance anxiety. I hate it.

I took my dick back out of my pants and looked at it in the mirror. I thought it looked nice. I milked it in my hands several times, trying to get the blood going where it should be. I imagined Taffy's smooth bare legs, and then her Spring skirt hiked up over her bare ass. What would her cunt look like? What would that ass feel like pressed against my hips? Her pretty face looking back at me over her shoulder?

I got aroused. I was feeling more confident. I reminded myself that the fantasy I was having could be a reality. I put little Ricky back in my pants and headed back for the table. Erica and Edwin were tickling each other and laughing. Taffy was saving my seat by putting her leg across it, allowing a view of her legs right up to her crotch, but not enough to see the goodies. OK, that's a sign.

As the night continued, the fun intensified. I ended up kissing Taffy, and boy was that amazing! I felt more of a charge kissing her than I ever had with any woman before her. My sister and Edwin were all over each other. Edwin even had his hand up her skirt on two occasions that I know of. I didn't do anything like that with Taffy, but the kissing was definitely hot. She even said at one point after a long kiss that she needed another napkin for her lap. It didn't occur to me right away what she meant, but after dancing a little while with her it really hit me and was all I could think about on our way back to my parents' house.

In the car, Ricky whispered to me that he was going to sneak off with my sister tonight if that was OK with me. I told him it was fine, and that all he had to do was climb up on the garage and she could crawl out her bedroom window and they could fuck their brains out on the roof. Erica had gotten away with that with previous boyfriends, so I figured that would be a good plan for them.

The girls went to my sister's bedroom. Edwin and I were bunking in my old bedroom, which is now Taffy's. As I lay in bed, dreaming of fucking Taffy, I couldn't help but notice how feminine my old bedroom was now. How many nights in my high school days had I laid awake, wishing I had a hot girl in my bed with me? Now a hot girl sleeps in it every night, and is probably waiting for me just down the hall. But out of respect for my parents, I'd wait an hour or so for the house to be silent so my parents could drift off. I was so excited I was jerking off without even realizing it.

"Hey, man! Save it for later!" Edwin giggled.

Oh man. There I was exposing my fully engorged cock to Ed, pumping it like a chimp. "Woah, sorry dude," I blushed. "Just thinking about Taffy."

"Don't think about her, man, do her!" He scolded.

"I will. I'm just going to wait a while, then go in there." I said.

"Me too. We'll go on the roof, and you two can fuck inside." He said, sounding not the least bit nervous.

So I laid there, quietly. Thinking about Taffy. Watching the clock. It was 12:22, I figured I'd just wait until 1:00.

After what seemed like a pause, I jolted when I heard the familiar sound of Edwin's heavy snoring. I rubbed my eyes and looked at the clock. It was 3:15! Edwin was wiped out beside me. He had apparently had his fill of sex with my sister--and who knows, maybe Taffy, too. Taffy was probably satisfied with Edwin and completely over me by now. I laid there totally pissed at myself.

I couldn't go back to sleep. Knowing that it was too late, I wanted to masturbate to relieve my sexual tension, but I was too depressed to get it up. I was pretty sure I'd missed out on Taffy's hot body, but I was determined to take one last look at her before daybreak, when I was certain to endure the easy let-down I had earned.

So I tiptoed down the hall in my briefs to Erica's room. I eased the door open and could see the forms of the girls sleeping in the twin beds. The nearest bed was Taffy's. Erica loved to sleep by the window, which was open, attesting to the romp she had just had with Edwin.

Taffy laid there, sleeping with a pillow half covering her head. It was a warm night and the light sheet she slept under was only up to her waist. I strained my eyes in the dim light to make out the form of her breast. My cock began to lengthen in my briefs. My breathing was uneasy. I wanted to touch her so badly. Instead I started touching myself.

As I cranked my cock over her sleeping form, I decided to blow my load right there over her instead of back in my room. I slid my underwear off and placed it beside her to receive my ejaculate.

As I started to get more excited, I got brave and lifted her sheet a little to see underneath. The view was insufficient, so I slowly peeled the linen back, exposing her sweet naked tush to the night air. I could dimly, but definitely, see the firm, round contours of her back and ass in the muted moonlight.

I froze and held my breath as she stirred for a second, rolling over onto her back. There were the tits. There was the stomach. There was her neatly trimmed bush. Still not breathing, I slowly placed my hand back on my rigid tool. Curiously, I saw her hand slide down her belly to her clit and begin circling slowly.

I watched, nervously. Was she waking up? Her slender little hand continued working at her mound. Her other hand rose to touch her breast. My God, I thought, she's going to masturbate! Surely she'd catch me here. I decided to duck down behind her bed before she could catch me, but it was too late.

"There you are!" she whispered. "I thought you were never going to come!"

"Shhh," I cautioned, not wanting anyone to hear us.

Her arms reached up to me. My auto pilot switched on and I immediately climbed on top of her. My penis was rock hard and oozing from the tip. I began deeply kissing her and sampling every inch of her body with my hands. In response, her pelvis pressed upward against my thigh, creating a streak of her own wetness.

We were unable to hold back. My aching cock found its mark, and burrowed into her wet slit. We were both trembling and taking turns sucking each other's nipples as I drove into her. At times I held myself over her and allowed her to fuck me, bucking her her hips upward at me, her hungry pussy tightly gripping my rod.

I was surprised I lasted very long. After many minutes of grinding away, we slowed our pace and changed positions. We flipped around into a 69 position and slurped away at each other for maybe half an hour. Her technique was really good! I found just the right trick with my tongue and persisted until her crotch began to thrust and twitch uncontrollably. I was making her come! The thrill of the moment pushed me over the edge, too. I tried to pull my cock out of her mouth in time, but she was sucking on it so hard through her climax that my pent-up jam had to blast down her throat. She seemed to have anticipated it. She swallowed each gush without missing a beat. She'd obviously done that before.

We both laid there panting with our faces in each other's slimy genitals, stroking each other's backs and legs. Within a few minutes we were at it again, sucking and stroking. The night continued with me fucking her doggy style for almost an hour, ending with an equally violent eruption of cum all over her back. I cleaned her up with my underwear and kissed her good night, then made it back to my room at 5:00 a.m. I dozed off in amazement at the frenzied passion I had just experienced with Taffy.

I slept no more than 3 hours. I awoke to see Erica sitting at the foot of my bed. Edwin was still sawing logs.

"Hey, had a good night, didn't you?" I whispered.

Erica grinned from ear to ear and glanced at Edwin. "Yeah, you got a second?" She said, gesturing that she wanted to talk to me in the hall.

"Sure," I nodded. "Hand me my bath robe." She handed me my robe and diverted her eyes while I put it on. I couldn't wait to hear what she and Edwin had done, but even more I wanted to know what Taffy had reported to her. I followed her into the hall.

"Did you and Taffy do it?" She asked.

I cracked a guilty smile and nodded.

"You two must have been very quiet!" She laughed.

I laughed too. "We must have been. Honestly, we just went nuts on each other. Maybe Edwin's snoring kept everyone from hearing. Taffy gave me the hottest night of my life! Did she say anything to you?"

"No way," sister replied, "she's been zonked out all morning. I haven't been able to sleep since Edwin left my room."

"Oh, really?" I asked. "How'd it go with him?"

"Well, he didn't come in until after 3:00 in the morning. I stayed up waiting but must have dozed off around 2:00, but I woke up and there he was. Believe me, it was REALLY worth the wait. We fucked like animals for two hours! I guess he's going to sleep in for quite a while."

No way, I thought to myself. Did I just fuck my sister all night? I couldn't have made such an oversight. "Umm," I hesitated, "did you two fuck out on the roof?"

"No," she sighed, "Taffy slept by the window, she's afraid to sleep close to a doorway and she liked the breeze. I figured you two could use the roof."

I stared into my dear sister's eyes. She didn't have a clue what had just happened. Edwin had drifted off like the hard sleeper he is. Taffy had done the same. There I stood, my loins still tingling from our hard ride, the smell of her juices still on my face, and a generous helping of my semen in her stomach. My sister didn't know!

"I want to go wake him up," Erica said. "I'm still so turned on!" She started toward my old room.

"Wait!" I gasped, grabbing her arm. "Erica, that wasn't Edwin."

"Huh?"

"That wasn't Edwin!" I sighed very hard, closed my eyes and forced out the words. "That was me. I thought you slept in your regular bed. I thought you were Taffy and you thought I was Edwin! That was ME."

I opened my eyes. Erica looked like she had just been hit on the head. She wandered into my bedroom and lifted the sheets and looked at Edwin.

"Boxers!" she gasped. She walked back to me with her mouth wide open. Her agape lips curled up into a surprised smile. She started laughing. She put her arms around me to keep from falling over. "Oh my GOD!"

I couldn't believe how well she was taking this. She laughed for a good two minutes. "You OK about this?" I asked.

"I can't believe we didn't have a clue!" She exclaimed.

"What are we going to tell them?" I asked.

"Nothing, moron!" She said, smacking me on the head. "But, God, Ricky, you were great!" She was laughing again. "I always wondered what it would be like with you!"

I nervously laughed in response. "Umm, you were pretty fucking awesome, yourself." I just loved her for taking this so well. I was mentally preparing myself for expulsion from the family. But Erica always had a great perspective and sense of humor about everything.

"Oh ... my ... GOD!" she repeated. She stared at me, smiling, for about five seconds, then asked, "so, are you going to fuck Taffy this morning? She's really wanting it and Mom and Dad already left for church."

"Umm. I don't know." I whispered. I looked at my sister for some sense of direction. My mind was blown.

Erica shoved me in the direction of her room. "Get in there and give it to her like you did to me. I've got to fuck SOMEBODY right now and it can't be you with other people in the house about to wake up."

I shuffled into my sister's bedroom toward Taffy. Sure enough, Taffy and I fucked all morning long. My sister, meanwhile, drained Edwin three times. We never told Taffy and Edwin what took place the night before. Erica also never said anything to me about it after our talk in the hall.

As Edwin and I drove back to our school that night, I couldn't help but wonder what the future would hold for my twin sister and me. What she said in the hall really sounded like she'd be willing to try it again. Taffy was really great, and I'd like to keep seeing her, but I just couldn't get the memory of sex with Erica out of my head, including her delighted reaction to discovering our blunder.

So what should I do if Erica comes to me sometime, wanting a rematch?

Members can rate and comment on the stories at Firegirls.com!

BACK TO STORIES SAMPLE PAGE  |  HOME